The Writing Life with Virgil Mathes
  • Home
  • About Me
  • My Novels
  • Writing
    • Academic Work >
      • Curriculum Vitae
      • Rhetoric and The Duel
    • Fiction
    • Poetry
  • Writin' the River
  • Contact
  • Friends

Writin' The River

My little space on the 'net  to discuss …

The Long and Short of the 45

4/25/2021

0 Comments

 
​
If one wanted to stir up a hornet’s nest in an online sixgun group, one of the best ways is to post any question or comment concerning the “45 Long Colt.”   Keyboard commandos will come out of the woodwork to correct the innocent poster that there is no such cartridge . . . they must surely mean the 45 Colt, which is the proper and official name of the round. And of course they do, and hopefully the original poster’s question gets answered after the ceremonial comeuppance. But this misnomer persists; the venerable 45 Colt has somehow picked up the erroneous title of “Long Colt” somewhere along the way. How could that be?
The misnomer persists largely because the 45 Colt really did come in a couple of sizes, as seen here: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/.45_Colt#/media/Fichier:Colt_.45_LC_Cartridges.JPG 

There are two standard answers; the first being that the “Long Colt” is to distinguish the 45 Colt from the later 45 ACP.  This could make some sense given that both the 45 ACP and the 45 Colt served side by side in the World Wars, with the shorter ACP round chambered in the 1911 and the longer 45 in the big New Service Colt and Triple Lock Smith & Wesson revolvers. That one round feeds a semi-automatic and the other a revolver makes this version feel a little thin, as there are bigger differences to note than cartridge length. The second version, which perhaps sounds more credible on its surface, is that the “Long Colt” was to distinguish the more powerful cartridge from the shorter 45 S&W (also called 45 Govt), which was standard Army issue beginning in 1874 to fill the Smith & Wesson “Schofield” top-break revolver.  This also makes sense since the shorter S&W round was actually issued for Army troops because it would chamber in either revolver, but a civilian who wanted the longer (slightly more powerful) cartridge might well ask a shopkeeper for “the long Colts” to differentiate between the two. This explanation has the ring of truth insofar as being historically possible, as both cartridges were in use during this time frame.  A variant of this story is that the advent of Cowboy Action Shooting (CAS) created a need to differentiate between the original “long Colt” and newer “45 Cowboy,” which is a still shorter case to accommodate the extremely light charges of smokeless powder favored by the gamesmen, but I don’t believe this – the “Long Colt” term is far older than the Cowboy cartridge.
 
There is some history of cartridges having more than one name; Winchester introduced the highly successful 1873 lever action in their proprietary 44 Winchester CenterFire (WCF) cartridge and later in the 38 WCF, both of which were popular enough for Colt to chamber in their flagship single action.  Colt, however, was loathe to put a Winchester name on their product, and instead called them by their powder charge, and so the 44-40 & 38-40 were born. It is considered correct to refer to these cartridges by either name. 
 
But a manufacturer putting a name on their product, even if they are simply renaming an existing cartridge, still lends a legitimacy that the “Long Colt” designation seems to lack.  The name “45 Long Colt” sometimes appears on ammunition boxes, but is this enough to recognize the popular misnomer?
 
For my money, yes, it is enough. People call the 45 the “Long Colt” and through long usage that has become (for better or worse) an accepted and widely understood alternate name for the cartridge. The whole debate is a non-starter; whether or not the “Long Colt” designation is official or not (it’s not) is irrelevant; when a shooter refers to the cartridge by this name everyone knows what they mean. Perhaps this attitude dates back to my youth, when I saw Ruger single actions with “45Colt” tags alongside reloaded ammo labeled “45 Long Colt” and yet somehow no one was confused or offended. It was a simpler time, with less strident labeling expectations.
 
But don’t take my word for it; noted gunwriter Mike Venturino has weighed in on this debate, and he has done far more shooting and research into the cartridges of the 19th century than most.  In his article “All American 45s” he notes that not only was there the original 45 “Long” Colt and the 45 Govt, or Schofield, but Remington-UMC made 45 cartridges head stamped “45 Colt” that were clearly loaded in shorter cases (but not quite the same length as the Schofield) with the original narrow case rims of the longer, standard 45 Colt. So they were neither fish nor fowl, but their own hybrid cartridge. So perhaps the “Long Colt” crowd has a leg to stand on after all.
 
See his article here: https://www.magzter.com/article/Mens-Interest/Handloader/All-American-45s
​
 
 
So, if we give up on the 45 “Long” Colt debate, what’s left for us to quibble about on social media? Well, there’s always correcting people who refer to box magazines as “clips.”
 
 

0 Comments

    Author

    Join me as I postulate about literature, popular culture, martial arts, and who knows what else.

    Archives

    July 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    October 2019
    June 2018
    April 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    November 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015

    Categories

    All
    1860 Army
    21 Foot Rule
    45-70
    Adult Choices
    Andres Moreno
    Arizona
    Arizona Rangers
    Bagwell
    Ballad Of The Laurie Swain
    Battle Blade
    Battle Blades
    Battle School
    Ben Foster
    Big Iron
    Bill Jordan
    BLM
    Bone Tomahawk
    Book Review
    Bowie
    Brotherhood
    Cancel Culture
    Case Bowie
    Chopped
    Christian Bale
    Civil Rights
    Clear Creek
    Cold Steel
    Color Guard
    Colt
    Community Service
    Confederate
    COVID
    CustomerService
    Darren Castle
    Defensive
    Democracy
    DiCaprio
    Dinosaur
    Donald Sutherland
    Doug Peacock
    Education
    Expendables Bowie
    Family
    Flu
    Forsaken
    Fortress
    Frank Williams
    Freedom
    Frontier
    Gary Johnson
    Greeting
    Grey Westerns
    Grizzly Years
    Harley Davidson
    Hateful Eight
    Helles Belle
    HEMA
    Heroes
    High School
    Hillary
    Hobgoblins
    Honor
    Hostiles
    Hugh Glass
    Infantry
    James Keating
    Jill Stein
    Jurassic World
    Just Be
    Justified
    Keep Rubber Side Down
    Keifer Sutherland
    Kindle
    Knife
    Learning
    Legacy
    Lever Action
    Lynne Holliday
    Mandated
    Marlin
    Marty Robbins
    Memorial
    Michigan
    Mogollon Rim
    Monuments
    Motorcycle
    Mountain Men
    Movie Review
    Movie Reviews
    Movie Violence
    Musso Bowie
    Natchez Bowie
    Navajo
    Officer Darrin Reed
    Old West
    Phoenix Society
    Plowshare Forge
    Police
    Presidential Race 2016
    Quentin Tarantino
    Ranger
    Ranger Up
    Range War
    Rebirth
    Relax
    Revenant
    River
    River City Sheath
    Roomba
    SAA
    Seminar
    Service
    Short Story Collection
    Show Low
    Skinwalkers
    State Firearm
    Statues
    Student
    Success
    Swordsmanship
    Third Party Candidates
    Thuer
    Tolerance
    Tony Hillerman
    Training
    Trump
    Utopia
    Vacuum
    Volunteer
    Water Closet
    Wattpad
    Welcome
    Wes Studi
    Westerns
    Wilderness
    Winchester
    Writing

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.